Saturday, February 1, 2014

Who is the Best Math Tutor in Lexington, KY?

By Anna Seacat

Are you looking for a math tutor in Lexington, KY?
The reasons that parents find themselves looking for the best math tutor in Lexington, KY are many.  Some parents wish to supplement the current curriculum in public and private schools in Lexington to ensure their students are prepared for placement tests and high school-level math.  While other parents choose to home-school their children, but value programs that enrich their own math lessons.  Some parents in Lexington, KY are discouraged by recent test results and want to raise their child’s math scores.  Others have a child in one of the gifted and talented programs in Lexington, KY and are searching out a math enrichment program.  While still others may be frustrated, because their child is struggling through daily math homework.  Or, if you are like me, you are the type of parent who wants their child to excel academically. 

Regardless of your reasoning, if you fall into one of the above categories, until now, you would have had to embark on a great research journey to find the best math tutor in Lexington, KY.  To take the pain out of that journey, I have compiled a comparison of all of the math tutoring programs, math enrichment programs, and after school math programs in Lexington, KY.  I hope this comparison helps you to make the best decision for your child. 


WyzAnt | Tutoring

WyzAnt versus KUMON | Lexington, KY
WyzAnt Tutoring is an online advertising platform for private math tutors.  In Lexington, KY, slightly less than 100 math tutors are advertising their services on the WyzAnt site.  These tutors charge anywhere from $25 - $65 / hour.  The site allows you to filter by the gender of the tutor, highest/lowest price per hour, distance from your home, and ratings.  Most tutors have a bio with a picture to advertise their qualifications. 
I was shocked to see that almost 100 people in Lexington, KY claim to be math tutors.  Since I’m the type of consumer, who boils my options down to the “top ten,” my analysis below will focus on the top ten math tutors listed on the aforementioned site based on their ratings in Lexington, KY. 

TUTOR’S GENDER.  I appreciated how a parent can filter by gender, because at least for me, I would rather a woman work in a one-to-one tutoring environment with my daughters than a male.  Of course, that’s just my personal preference.  Of the top 10 math tutors in Lexington, KY listed, half were women.  So, we are off to a good start. 

TUTOR’S AREA OF FOCUS.  My children are in elementary school.  Consequently, I read the bios of each of the 5 best math tutors in Lexington, KY and found that only 2 had listed tutoring young children as their direct experience.  If you go to WyzAnt’s website and perform the search for the best math tutor in Lexington, KY, as I did, you will find that all of the top 10 tutors, with the exception of one, are math or science graduate students, who are tutoring on the side to make extra cash.  I have an issue with this, because I wanted whatever solution I chose for my daughter’s math tutor to be laser focused on math education – I want it to be their career and what they were professionally trained in.  In other words, just because you are a whiz at math does not mean you are trained and experienced in teaching the way to learn math.

TUTOR’S FEES.  Even if I could get over the fact that most of the tutors on WyzAnt were not professionally trained in teaching math, I also found the hourly rates to be unaffordable for most parents in Lexington, KY.  My budget was around $100 per month per child.  However, the average rate of the best rated tutors in Lexington was $41.50 per hour, meaning at my budget, I would get less than 2.5 hours of tutoring for each of my daughters each month.  Surely the best math tutoring solution in Lexington, KY should include more than a few hours of work each month. 

WyzAnt | Tutoring Summary.  If you are looking for the best math tutor in Lexington, KY and have a considerable budget to spend each month, $300+ per month, than a private in-home tutor found through WyzAnt.com might be an option for you.  As for me, my search goes on.

Sylvan Learning

Sylvan Learning Center versus KUMON | Lexington, KY
While there is not a Sylvan Learning Center within 100 miles of Lexington, KY, I was still interested in the program since it has considerable brand recognition, and I was curious how much its online program cost.  Unfortunately, I called at 10:38 on a Monday morning to inquire about Sylvan’s online learning program, and as of Thursday no one had returned my call.



TakeLessons.com

TakeLessons.com versus KUMON | Lexington, KY
The TakeLessons website felt like way too much of a sales pitch for me to seriously consider it in my research.  When I went to the site, I could not find any information about their process for screening tutors, estimated cost, etc.  In fact, the company wanted my personal information before I could go any further into the site.  No thank you.  If you are set on an in-home tutor and have a decent budget, I would recommend going to WyzAnt’s website.




Craigslist

I have serious doubts that the best math tutor in Lexington, KY is going to be the hidden gem on Craigslist.com.  However, for our research purposes, I did investigate the options.  I found two listings for tutors who addressed math for young children; both tutors charged $35 per hour.

Care.com | TutorSelect.com | PurpleMath.com

The search infrastructure on Care.com, TutorSelect.com, PurpleMath.com frustrated me.  I could only search by “tutor” in Lexington, KY.  I could not filter by subject, gender of the instructor, distance from my house, ratings, price for services, etc.  For instance, although Care.com turned up 150 results for tutor in Lexington, KY.  I was not about to waste my time shuffling through each bio.  There are clearly better ways to find the best math tutor in Lexington, KY.

KUMON

KUMON is the best alternative to math tutoring in Lexington, KY
WHAT KUMON IS NOT.  So, for anyone who has ever asked, “What is KUMON?”  The big and unexpected answer is that KUMON is not actually a tutoring service at all – at least not what most Americans perceive tutoring to be.  Although KUMON doesn’t meet our Western perception of what tutoring is (an adult helping a child or teen do their school homework), it is actually superior to that conception. 

A SOLUTION RATHER THAN A BAND-AIDE.  Instead of helping a child struggle through work that is sent home from school, KUMON has created a way for children to learn the fundamental skills that are the root cause behind their struggles.  In other words, KUMON is the best way to learn and master basic skills in reading and math in Lexington, KY.  When your child has mastered the basics, she or he will find her homework from school to be easy.  In this sense, KUMON is designed to be a life-long solution to learning, rather than a band-aide to current struggles in school.   

NO CRUTCHES ALLOWED IN KUMON.  Additionally, while KUMON teaches your child a better way of learning math and reading, it also helps them to become independent learners.  The KUMON methodology believes that tutors are crutches; if you hire a tutor for your child now, they will need one in college.  Meanwhile, their peers, who are independent learners, will be excelling in colligate level studies without any crutch to lean on.

KUMON helps to raise children as independent learners. | Lexington, KY
HOW MUCH DOES KUMON CHARGE?  KUMON’s fees are a straight-forward monthly payment.  Most KUMON centers charge between $100-$115 per month per student for one subject.  This fee includes unlimited access to the KUMON director in Lexington, KY, Sudha Chopra, who will be instrumental in helping your child learn to be an independent learner.  It also includes KUMON’s learning method, which will be catered on a weekly and daily basis to your child’s needs.  Your child’s KUMON exercises will be unique to your child and be constantly adjusted to ensure her mastery of each math (or reading) skill. 





The Tutoring Club

A HYBRID APPROACH.  I was actually shocked to see that a hybrid of private tutoring and KUMON exists.  This is exactly what the company, The Tutoring Club, LLC., tries to offer residents in Lexington, KY.  The Tutoring Club employs private tutors to carry-out a KUMON-like methodology.  Additionally, like a private tutor’s offering, the Tutoring Club does provide help with school homework and will prepare students for standardized tests and placement exams. 

The Tutoring Club versus KUMON | Lexington, KY
Additionally, unlike KUMON, who sees their learning methodology as a life-long journey (in Japan babies are taking KUMON, which is producing 2 year-olds who know how to read, and Japanese seniors are showing diminished signs of dementia while in the program),  The Tutoring Club will give parents a specific time-frame to meet a set goal.  In other words, while KUMON (true to Japanese form) sees learning as a life-long process that never should end, The Tutoring Club will give parents an ETA, of sorts.

AN EXPENSIVE APPROACH.  For example, from what I can gather from my research, say your child is falling behind his peers in first grade math.  You can bring this challenge to The Tutoring Club, which might respond with the goal of getting your first grader working above grade level in 64 hours spread over a period of 4-8 months for an estimate of $2,800.00.  So, essentially, in this scenario, The Tutoring Club is charging you around $43.75 per tutoring hour.

A MOTHER’S CONCERNS.  At first, The Tutoring Club seemed like the best of both worlds; it offered a service where I could bring my child to get help with school homework and, or reach a specific and quantifiable goal.  However, as a mother, I found some things that bothered me about The Tutoring Club as a company.    

First, unlike KUMON, which is a Japanese methodology of learning math and reading and has been finely tuned and perfected over the past fifty years by experts in academia, The Tutoring Club was established in the 1990s.  Therefore, The Tutoring Club’s exercises, which deliver its method, are still being adjusted and edited.  In fact, I read on GlassDoor.com about one of their employees being embarrassed by typos in The Tutoring Club’s class work.   I’m pretty sure that KUMON’s founder, Toro Kumon, would roll over in his grave if a teacher ever found a typo in any KUMON exercise.  In other words, KUMON has spent over a half century fine tuning and streamlining its method and medium.

Second, from a business perspective, I was concerned to learn that even though The Tutoring Club has been established since 1991, there are only 122 locations world-wide.  And, perhaps even more worrisome, is that the company is not growing.  In fact, it is in a state of negative growth; in 2010, there were 143 Tutoring Club centers in the U.S., but that number dropped to 112 by 2013.  Perhaps the cause of the slow year-over-year growth and the negative growth in the past few years is a corporate or an operational issue. Nevertheless, as a parent, I worry about whether or not the method is experiencing difficulties at the center-level, which would certainly affect my children. 

Last, as mentioned above, cost is a huge factor in my search for the best math tutor in Lexington, KY.  The Tutoring Club, like private tutors in Lexington, charges by the hour.  Not surprisingly, the cost for both options is similar, around $41/hr.  Although that expense doesn’t work for my budget, I can see pros and cons with both a private tutor and The Tutoring Club. 

For instance, as a person who is driven by results, I appreciate how The Tutoring Club sets a goal, tells parents how much money and time it will require to reach the goal, and then stands behind the results.  But, remember, that $41/hr estimate is not one-on-one tutoring with your child.  Tutors at The Tutoring Club tutor three students at a time and, obviously, the company pays its tutors a small fraction what it charges parents.  This scenario makes me wonder why a good, private tutor who can produce measurable results would ever work for The Tutoring Club.  On the other hand, I’m not confident that a private tutor in Lexington, KY would be willing or have the know-how to set a specific goal and work backwards to achieve that goal in a set time-frame as the Tutoring Club does.    

And The Winner Is…

KUMON takes the prize for the best alternative to math tutoring in Lexington, KY
So, after conducting all of my research, who am I prepared to give the title to as, “The best math tutor in Lexington, KY?”  Well, there is no easy way to answer this, because every parent’s situation is different.  I am focused on my daughters excelling academically throughout their entire academic career, plus I am constrained to a monthly budget (I can just imagine trying to convince my husband to pay a tutor $2,800 for 4 months of work), so for me KUMON is the best math tutor in Lexington, KY

However, if you are a parent who is not limited to a budget and wants someone to come to your home several times a week to help your children complete their homework from school, then, by all means, a private tutor is a good option.  On the other hand, if I did live that glorious budget-free lifestyle, I would also pay my private tutor to take my children to KUMON a couple of times a week.  This scenario is ideal, because the private tutor could help them with the homework that their school sends home every day, and KUMON would be simultaneously preparing them for collegiate-level mathematics.   

I hope this comparison has helped you determine what the best math tutoring solution is for your Lexington, KY family.  I’d love to hear about your tutoring stories and reviews.  Please email them to me at seacatanna@gmail.com

No comments:

Post a Comment